The Ambiguity of Criminalizing Business Decisions: An Analysis of Legal Realism and the Business Judgment Rule in Supreme Court Decision Number 121 K/Pid.Sus/2020
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.28946/rpt.v15i1.5411Abstract
The phenomenon of criminalizing business decisions within State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs) shows that there is a serious tension between the logic of corporate governance and the goal of eradicating corruption. The Supreme Court Decision No. 121 K/Pid.Sus/2020 regarding the acquisition of BMG Australia by PT Pertamina (Persero) is an example of how managerial actions carried out through legitimate corporate procedures can be construed as criminal acts because they lead to state losses. This study aims to analyze the ambiguity of the criminalization of business risk through a doctrinal legal approach combined with the perspective of legal realism. The research method uses a conceptual analysis of the Business Judgment Rule as a standard of accountability of the board of directors in decision-making, as well as a case approach to the Supreme Court's legal considerations with qualitative analysis techniques based on juridical reasoning. The results of the study show that judges emphasize more on the results of decisions in the form of state losses as an indicator of error, so that the line between economic risk and unlawful acts becomes blurred. This condition poses a potential chilling effect that can hinder the courage of the board of directors in carrying out business strategies in risk-intensive SOEs. This research contributes to the need to reformulate the application of Business Judgment Rule in corporate corruption cases to prevent excessive criminalization of business decisions that are not based on malicious intent or conflict of interest.References
Atikah, Ika. Legal Research Methods. Edited by Zulfa and Nita. I. Sukabumi: CV Haura Utama, 2022. Accessed December 23, 2024. https://repository.uinbanten.ac.id/9155/1/P Hukum.pdf Research Methods.
Beebeejaun, Ambareen, and Pramod Bissessur. "The Business Judgment Rule as a Protective Armor for Directors' Responsibilities: A Comparative Study Among Mauritius, United Kingdom, and United States". Statute Law Review 45, no. 2 (2024). https://www.scopus.com/inward/record.uri?eid=2-s2.0-85194926708&doi=10.1093%2Fslr%2Fhmae028&partnerID=40&md5=78adf051d00acfb34129759b9d58029f.
Bimantara bimantara, Raka Abel. "Analysis of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) Reports During the Covid-19 Pandemic at Pertamina Laksda Adisucipto Yogyakarta". Commicast (2022).
Bindreiter, Utah. Sweden: Legal philosophy in the 20th century. A Treatise of Legal Philosophy and General Jurisprudence: Volume 12 Legal Philosophy in the Twentieth Century: The Civil Law World, Volume 1: Language Areas, Volume 2: Main Orientations and Topics, 2016. https://www.scopus.com/inward/record.uri?eid=2-s2.0-85008958178&doi=10.1007%2F978-94-007-1479-3_21&partnerID=40&md5=280615fb58bbf0256775d7bfeb09bb33.
Public Relations Bureau, KPK RI. "State Losses of IDR 2.1 Trillion, KPK Designates Suspects for LNG Procurement Corruption at Pertamina". Press Release of the Corruption Eradication Commission of the Republic of Indonesia. Last modified September 21, 2023. Accessed December 23, 2024. https://www.kpk.go.id/id/ruang-informasi/berita/kerugian-negara-rp21-triliun-kpk-tetapkan-tersangka-korupsi-pengadaan-lng-di-pertamina.
Brejdak, Jakub. "Should be the CEO of the Company also a Philosopher? About the Principle of Business Judgment Rule which has been Codified in Poland; [Czy prezes spółki powinien być filozofem? O zasadzie business judgment rule, która doczekała się swojej kodyfikacji w Po". Prawo i Wiez 2021, no. 4 (2021): 256 – 271. https://www.scopus.com/inward/record.uri?eid=2-s2.0-85127306567&doi=10.36128%2Fpriw.vi38.172&partnerID=40&md5=d69e24d13cdc504ad52ae65bf3f75946.
Chiassoni, Pierluigi. "Some Realism about legislation". Theory and Practice of Legislation 1, no. 1 (2013): 173 – 186. https://www.scopus.com/inward/record.uri?eid=2-s2.0-84883861041&doi=10.5235%2F2050-8840.1.1.173&partnerID=40&md5=719538a2496508c954a2327a328ed739.
Scott, Victor. "The Dynamics of SOE Financial Management Regarding the 'Dilemma' between State Losses or Business Losses". Journal of Rechts Vinding: National Legal Development Media 9, no. 3 (December 8, 2020): 349.
Disemadi, Hari Sutra, Mochammad Abizar Yusro, and Ali Ismail Shaleh. "Legal Protection of Business Decisions of SOE Directors through Business Judgement Rule Doctrine". Journal of Jurisprudence (2020).
Faatin, Faradiba Nurjannah, Kurnia Ekasari, and Hesti Wahyuni. "Evaluation of the Development of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) Programs PT PERTAMINA (PERSERO)". Journal of Applied Business Taxation and Economics Research (2024).
Fadinah, Fadinah. "Corporate Social Responsibility Programs Analysis PT. Pertamina Indonesia in the Era of Pandemic Covid-19". Commicast (2022).
Faoziyah, Sitti. "Corporate Social Responsibility to Reduce Community Rejection of a Company Existence: Analysis of Business Ethics Perspective". Journal of Scientech Research and Development (2022).
Ferreira, Bruno, and Manuel Sequeira. Business Judgement Rule as a safeguard for ESG minded directors and a warning for others. The Palgrave Handbook of ESG and Corporate Governance, 2022. https://www.scopus.com/inward/record.uri?eid=2-s2.0-85161940104&doi=10.1007%2F978-3-030-99468-6_14&partnerID=40&md5=b80f06f472bdf284e0958562310739d2.
Supreme Court, Republic of Indonesia. Decision of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Indonesia No. 121 K/Pid.Sus/2020 (2020).
Marra, Realino. "A new reflection on legal realism. The American realists; [NUOVA MEDITAZIONE SUL REALISMO GIURIDICO REALISTI D'America]". Materiali per una Storia della Cultura Giuridica 55, no. 1 (2025): 5 – 33. https://www.scopus.com/inward/record.uri?eid=2-s2.0-105012413584&doi=10.1436%2F117573&partnerID=40&md5=02f6e85dd7bf701e43d39c1202367e2e.
Neri-Castracane, Giulia. "Does the business judgment rule help promote corporate social responsibility?" Frontiers of Law in China 10, no. 1 (2015): 8–23. https://www.scopus.com/inward/record.uri?eid=2-s2.0-85031500907&doi=10.3868%2Fs050-004-015-0003-8&partnerID=40&md5=e1aae653f19131621d6db7b330511234.
Octaviana, Shoraya Lolyta. "Corporate Social Responsibility Communication Strategy at PT Pertamina (Persero) Region IV in Central Java and Yogyakarta". Journal of the Messenger (2013).
Pangestu, Ririh Aji. "Analysis of Dynamics and Restructuring of PT Pertamina (Persero)". JKMP (Journal of Public Policy and Management) (2023).
Polyakov, Andrey. "The St. Petersburg School of Legal Philosophy and Russian Legal Thought". Law and Philosophy Library 125 (2018): 1–35. https://www.scopus.com/inward/record.uri?eid=2-s2.0-85113678097&doi=10.1007%2F978-3-319-98821-4_1&partnerID=40&md5=4822576b1caad233a348235d4edeb1cb.
Pratiwi, Windi Dwi, and Dini Gandini Purbaningrum. "Implementation of Good Corporate Governance Principles in the Human Resources Division at PT Pertamina Central". Publicity Journal of Public Administration Studies (2023).
Raffles, Raffles. "Responsibility and Legal Protection of the Board of Directors in the Management of a Limited Liability Company". Law: Journal of Law 3, no. 1 (July 7, 2020): 107–137.
Schlegel, John Henry. Legal Realism. International Encyclopedia of the Social & Behavioral Sciences: Second Edition, 2015. https://www.scopus.com/inward/record.uri?eid=2-s2.0-85043428018&doi=10.1016%2FB978-0-08-097086-8.86076-6&partnerID=40&md5=22095c9f2c52df75a61cb6f3d1ac62b2.
Shidarta. The Law of Reasoning and Legal Reasoning: Philosophical Roots. I. Bantul: Genta Publishing, 2013. https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Shidarta-Shidarta/publication/354053170_Hukum_Penalaran_dan_Penalaran_Hukum_Buku_1_Akar_Filosofis/links/612130b5232f955865a0e3d9/Hukum-Penalaran-dan-Penalaran-Hukum-Buku-1-Akar-Filosofis.pdf.
Tanjung, Afriansyah. "The Role and Discretion of Religious Court Judges in Handling Marriage Dispensation Applications: A Socio-Legal Study of Local Legal and Cultural Practices". Proceedings of Islamic Family Law, no. 5 (2025): 191–207. https://prosiding.stdiis.ac.id/index.php/hki/article/view/85.
Tanjung, Afriasnyah. "Introduction to Legal Research Method". In Introductory Module of Legal Research Methods of the S1 PJJ Law Study Program, Muhammadiyah Cyber University. I. Yogyakarta City: Muhammadiyah Cyber University, 2025.
———. "Strengthening Business Sustainability: One-Tier Boards System For Micro-Small Business Enterprises Resailnce After The Enacment Of Law Number 06 Of 2023 On Job Creation". Adijaya Journal of Multidisciplinary 1, no. 04 (August 11, 2023): 722-734–722–734. Accessed December 23, 2024. https://e-journal.naureendigition.com/index.php/jam/article/view/749.
Zaremby, Justin. legal realism And American law. Legal Realism and American Law, 2013. https://www.scopus.com/inward/record.uri?eid=2-s2.0-84904196429&partnerID=40&md5=0a4b8763a1e4ca013e514a79788eabe4.
Zenno Januarsyah, Mas Putra, Dwidja Priyatno, Agung Sujati Winata, and Khairul Hidayat. "The Application of the Doctrine of Business Judgment Rule in the Case of Karen Agustiawan's Corruption Crime". Journal of Ius Constituendum (2022).
Law No. 40 of 2007 concerning Limited Liability Companies (Statute Book of the Republic of Indonesia No. 106 of 2007, Supplement to Statute Book of the Republic of Indonesia No. 4756)
Law of the Republic of Indonesia Number 6 of 2023 concerning the Stipulation of Government Regulations in Lieu of Law Number 2 of 2022 concerning Job Creation into Law (Statute Book of the Republic of Indonesia Number 41 of 2023, Supplement to Statute Book of the Republic of Indonesia Number 6856)
Decision of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Indonesia Number 121K/Pid.Sus/2020
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
