Does the State Fail to Protect Defendant Rights in the Criminal Justice Process? A Case in Kosovo

Adelina Rakaj, Armend Podvorica

Abstract


The Republic of Kosovo is a new state that declared independence in 2008 and adopted its modern constitution also in 2008, where during twelve years the state has created a very advanced constitutional and legal system in terms of protection of freedoms and human rights in general. Also, in its legal system, Kosovo has built important mechanisms aimed at protecting the position of the defendant during criminal proceedings. Although Kosovo has established constitutional and legal guarantees for the protection of the rights of the defendant in the criminal process, the situation in practice is not satisfactory. The various data and reports reflected in this paper show that Kosovo has failed to meet the rights of the defendant and failed to protect these rights. Even this situation has continued continuously. What is disappointing about the defence of the defendant's rights is the fact that the regular courts have been careless, in enforcing the constitutional standards for the protection of the defendant's rights. In several cases, the courts have even failed to protect these rights. Kosovo's Constitutional Court is the only subject that has compensated, to some extent, the protection of the rights of the defendant. The paper reflects the practical situation in how much Kosovo has managed to apply and protect in practice the constitutional and legal guarantees offered by its legal system.

 


Keywords


Criminal Justice Sys-tem; ECHR; ECtHR; Rights of Defendants, People's Advocate; The Constitution of Kosovo.

Full Text:

PDF

References


Ajeti, Arbnor. “The Right to Use Legal Remedies Against Court Decisions in Contested Procedure.” Sriwijaya Law Review 4, no. 1 (2020): 9–22. https://doi.org/10.28946/slrev.Vol4.Iss2.428.pp9-22.

Al, Bajrami Arsin et. Introduction to the Legal System in Kosovo. Academy of Justice, Prishtina, 2019.

Al, Morina Visar et. “The Relationship between International Law and National Law in the Case of Kosovo: A Constitutional Perspective.” International Journal of Constitutional Law 9, no. 1 (2011): 275.

Akther, Shajeda., & Nordin, Rohaida. 2014. "Equality of Arms: A Fundamental Principle of Fair Trial Guarantee Developed by International and Regional Human Rights Instruments”, Legal Network Series, 1 LNS(A) lii.

Case no. KI06 / 12 Applicant Bajrush Gashi, Judgment- Constitutional Court of the Republic of Kosovo, June 27, 2012

Case no. KI104 / 16 Applicant Miodrag Paviҫ, Constitutional Review of the Judgment of the Supreme Court of Kosovo, PML-ZEC. no. 110/2016, dated 16 May 2016, Constitutional Court of the Republic of Kosovo on 04 August 2017

Case no. KI62 / 17 Applicant Emine Simnica, Judgment of the Constitutional Court of the Re-public of Kosovo, June 11, 2018.

Case no. Kl78 / 12 Applicant Bajrush Xhemajli, Judgment- Constitutional Court of the Repub-lic of Kosovo, on 22 June 2012.

Code no. 04 / L-123 of the Criminal Procedure of the Republic of Kosovo.

Constitution of the Republic of Kosovo, K-09042008, 2008.

Council of Europe. 2010. Recommendation CM / Rec (2010) 3 of the Committee of Ministers to member states on effective remedies for excessive length of proceedings.

Cukalovic, Enver Hasani and Ivan. Commentary: Constitution of the Republic of Kosovo. First Edit. Pristina: Deutsche Gesellschaft fur Internationale Zusammenarbeit -GIZ- GmbH, 2013.

European Commission, Progress Report for Kosovo, 2015.

European Commission, Progress Report for Kosovo, 2016.

European Commission, Progress Report for Kosovo, 2018.

European Commission, Progress Report for Kosovo, 2019.

Hager, Tamas. “Publicity as One of the Safeguards of Fair Trial in Criminal Procedure.” Curentul Juridic 60 (2015): 200.

Hasani, Enver. “Basic Characteristics of the Constitutional System in Kosovo.” Journal Law 1, no. 4 (2014): 7.

Institution of the People's Advocate of the Republic of Kosovo. 2016. Report on the recommendations of the People's Advocate of the Republic of Kosovo, Case no. 564/2016 Halili and others, regarding the rights of the defendant in the investigation phase and the filing of an indictment.

Institution of the People's Advocate of the Republic of Kosovo. 2017. Annual Report of the People's Advocate, no. 16, 2016.

Institution of the People's Advocate of the Republic of Kosovo. 2018. Ex officio report of the People's Advocate, no. 129/2018 regarding the effective solution of the procrastination of the court procedure - violation of the right within a reasonable time.

Institution of the People's Advocate of the Republic of Kosovo. 2017. Report no. 594/2017, Report with Recommendations of the People's Advocate regarding effective protection in criminal proceedings and guaranteeing the equality of the parties - the appointment of the defense counsel at public expense.

Institution of the People's Advocate of the Republic of Kosovo.2011. Recommended report of the People's Advocate, for taking immediate measures in order to implement Article 395 of the UNMIK / RREG / REG / 2003 / 26K of the Provisional Criminal Procedure Code (CPCCK), respectively the drafting and submission of a judgment by Supreme Court of Kosovo. It was addressed to Mr Enver Peci, Chairman of the Kosovo Judicial Council, June 17, 2011.

Law no. 06 / L - 054 On Courts. Official Gazette of the Republic of Kosovo / No. 22/18 December 2018, Prishtina.

Miftaraj, Ehat., Musliu, Betim. 2017. “Free Legal Assistance in Criminal Matters and the Implementation of the European Court of Human Rights Standards by the Courts of Kosovo ”. Kosovo Law Institut. Prishtina.

Morina. Visar., Korenica Fisnik and Doli Dren. 2011. “The relationship between international law and national law in the case of Kosovo: A Constitutional perspective” International Journal of Constitutional Law, Vol. 9 No. 1 274–296.

Papayannis, Dieogo M. “Independence, Impartiality and Neutrality in Legal Adjudication.” Revus 28 (2016): 52.

Podvorica, Armend; Rakaj, Adelina. The Guarantees of the Human Rights of the Defendant in the Law System in Kosovo. International Journal of Social Science Studies, [S.l.], v. 5, n. 11, p. 7-14, oct. 2017. ISSN 2324-8041.

Supreme Court of Kosovo, Prishtina, Judgment no. Pkl-Kzz 62/10.

The report of the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe Mission in Kosovo. 2016. Review of the implementation of the new Code of Criminal Procedure in Kosovo.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.28946/slrev.Vol4.Iss2.595.pp172-186

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Creative Commons License

Sriwijaya Law Review (SLRev) ISSN: 2541-5298 | e-ISSN: 2541-6464 is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

 
SLRev has been indexed by:
 
 
View full indexing services
 
SLRev Member of :                                    Plagiarism Detection by: