Internet Shutdown in Indonesia: An Appropriate Response or A Threat to Human Rights?
Abstract
In recent years, there has been an increase in the use of harsh censorship in several parts of the globe, notably Africa and Asia. In some cases, the shutdown may be justified, but in other cases, it is driven by the political interest of the regime. The research evaluates the Internet shutdowns in the post-2019 presidential election in Indonesia and during the social unrest in Papua Island. Using normative legal research, which uses statute, case, and comparative approach concludes that although Internet shutdowns in some situations are tolerable, their usage should be less frequent and more restricted. These explanations must be examined using legality, legitimacy, and proportionality principles to limit official arguments for Internet shutdowns because they infringe on human rights. However, since no enforcement mechanism exists, this is only a formality. The Indonesian government's decision to block Internet access to social media platforms during the 2019 presidential election riots and Papua social unrest is not an appropriate response because the decision violates the principles of declaration, proportionality, necessity, and legality, which must be respected even in an emergency situation. Furthermore, the ruling infringed on the civil rights to information controlled by Article 19 of the ICCPR as adopted by Law Number 12 of 2005. It also harmed several industries, including digital-based commerce. The research proffers alternative Internet policy choices for the government in response to the political escalation and social unrest.
Keywords
Full Text:
PDFReferences
AccessNow, “No More Internet Shutdowns! Let’s #KeepItOn”, Retrieved from https://www.accessnow.org/no-Internet-shutdowns-lets-keepiton/
AccessNow, “Targeted, Cut Off, and Left in the Dark”, Retrieved from https://www.accessnow.org/cms/assets/uploads/2020/02/KeepItOn-2019-report-1.pdf
Adrienne Russell et al, Culture: Media Convergence and Networked Participation. Networked Publics, edited by K. Varnelis, Cambridge: MIT Press Scholarship, (2008)
Aileen McHarg, “Reconciling Human Rights and the Public Interest: Conceptual Problems and Doctrinal Uncertainty in the Jurisprudence of the European Court of Human Rights,” Modern Law Review 52, no. 5, (1999).
Arfan Faiz Muhlizi, “Reformulation of Discretion in the Arrangement Administrative Law”, Jurnal Rechtsvinding, 1, no. 1, (2012).
B. D. Loader and D. Mercea, “Networking Democracy? Social Media Innovations in Partici-patory Politics”, Information, Communication and Society 14, no. 6, (2011).
Bank of America, “Trends in Consumer Mobility Report” (New York City: Bank of America, 2014), http://media.bizj.us/view/img/3099551/2014bactrendsinconsumermobilityreportinfographic.pdf.
Ben Wagner, “Understanding Internet Shutdowns: A Case Study from Pakistan”, International Journal of Communication 12, (2018).
Bend Bland, 2019, “The Mind-Boggling Challenge of Indonesia’s Election Logistic”, The Lowy Institute, Retrieved from https://www.lowyinstitute.org/the-interpreter/mind-boggling-challenge-indonesian-election-logistics.
Budi Hernawan, Torture and Peacebuilding in Indonesia: The Case of Papua, Contemporary Southeast Asia, Abingdon: Routledge, 2018.
Charles Manga Fombad, "Cameroon's Emergency Powers: A Recipe for (Un) Constitutional Dictatorship?", Journal of African Law 1, no. 1, 2004.
Christian Kreuder-Sonnen, Emergency powers of international organisations: Between normalisation and containment, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2019.
Clay Shirky, The Political Power of Social Media: Technology, the Public Sphere, and Politi-cal Change, New York: Council on Foreign Relations, 2011.
Constitutional Court Decision Number 81/PUU-XVIII/2020 dated October 27 2021.
D. Djohari, “Penerapan Norma Hukum Tata Negara Darurat Serta Kaitannya Dengan Pe-nanggulangan Gangguan Keamanan dan Bencana Tsunami di Provinsi Nanggroe Aceh Darussalam”, Jurnal Ilmu Hukum 2, no. 3, (2011).
Dominic McGodrick, “The Interface Between Public Emergency Powers and International Law”, International Journal of Constitucional Law 2, No. 2, (2004).
Edward Aspinal and et. al, “The Yudhoyono Presidency: Indonesia’s Decade of Stability and Stagnation”, (2015).
Edward Aspinall and Eve Warburton, “Indonesia: The Dangers of Democratic Regression”, Advances in Social Sciences, Education and Humanities Research 129, (2017).
Espen Geelmuyden Rød and Nils B. Weidmann, “Empowering Activists or Autocrats? The Internet in Authoritarian Regimes”, Journal of Peace Research 52, no. 3, (2015).
Evgeny Morozov, The Net Delusion: The Dark Side of Internet Freedom, New York: Public Affairs, 2011.
Filipe Brito Bastos and Anniek de Ruijter. "Break or bend in case of emergency?: Rule of law and state of emergency in European public health administration", European Journal of Risk Regulation, 10, no. 4, (2019).
Frederick Cowell, "Sovereignty and the Question of Derogation: An Analysis of Article 15 of the ECHR and the Absence of a Derogation Clause in the ACHPR." Birkbeck L. Rev. 1 (2013).
Global Internet Liberty Campaign, Regardless of Frontiers, Washington DC: Center for De-mocracy and Technology, (1998).
H. L. A. Hart, “Discretion”, Harvard Law Review 127, no. 2, (2013).
Human Rights Council, Thirty-Second Session, Promotion and protection of all human rights, civil, political, economic, social, and cultural rights, including the right to development, A//HRC/32/L.20, (2016).
Human Rights Watch, The Internet in the Mideast and North Africa, New York: Human Rights Watch. 1999.
J. A. G. M. Van Dijk, “Digital Democracy: Vision and Reality”, Public Administration in the Information Age: Revisited, (2012)
Jørgensen, Rikke Frank, “Internet and Freedom of Expression”, LLM Dissertation, Raoul Wal-lenberg Institute of Human Rights and Humanitarian Law-Lund University, (2001).
Khairil Azmin Mokhtar, Constitutional Law and Human Rights in Malaysia, Selangor: Sweet & Maxwell Asia, (2013).
Kresimir Kamber, "Limiting State Responsibility under the European Convention on Human Rights in Time of Emergency: An Overview of the Relevant Standards." European and Comparative Law Journal 5, no. 1 (2017).
Leonie Tanggahma, “A History of the Morning Star Flag of West Papua, West Papua Media, (2012), Retrieved from https://westpapuamedia.info/2012/12/02/a-history-of-the-morning-star-flag-of-west-papua/
Maire Leadbeater, “Conflict in West Papua”. Pacific Journalism Review 21, Issue 1, (2015).
Manfred Nowark, Introduction to the International Human Rights Regime, Martinus Nijhoff Publishers (2005).
Merlyna Lim, “Many Clicks but Little Sticks: Social Media Activism in Indonesia”, Journal of Contemporary Asia 43, no. 4, (2013).
Muhammad Yasin and et. al., Anotasi Undang-Undang No. 30 Tahun 2014 tentang Admin-istrasi Pemerintahan, Jakarta: Universitas Indonesia-Center for Study of Governance and Administrative Reform (UI-CSGAR), 2017.
Nahed Eltantawy and J. B. Weist, “Social Media in the Egyptian Revolution: Reconsidering Resource Mobilisation Theory”, International Journal of Communication 5, (2011).
Netblocks, “Indonesia Blocks Social Media as Election Protests Escalate”, Netblocks.org, (2019), Retrieved from https://netblocks.org/reports/indonesia-blocks-social-media-as-election-protests-escalate-XADE7LBg
Oren Gross and Fionnuala Ní Aoláin, Law in Times of Crisis: Emergency Powers in Theory and Practice 46. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2006.
Osgar S Matompo, “Pembatasa terhadap Hak Asasi Manusia dalam Perspektif Keadaan Da-rurat”, Jurnal Media Hukum 21, no. 1, (2014),
P. N. Howard and et. al, “The Dictators’ Digital Dilemma: When Do States Disconnect Their Digital Networks”, Issues in Technology Innovation 12, 2011,
Phelim Kipe, “Indonesia’s Papua Media Blacklist: Authorities Equate Journalism with Doing Something Wrong to Indonesia”, Human Rights Watch, (2018), Retrieved from https://www.hrw.org/news/2018/08/06/indonesias-papua-media-blacklist-0
Phil Robertson. Myanmar Again Cuts Rakhine State’s Internet. Human Rights Watch. (2020). Retrieved from https://www.hrw.org/news/2020/02/05/myanmar-again-cuts-rakhine-states-internet
PRI, “Pakistanis Question Government’s Use of Bans on Cell Phones, Other Tech”, (2013), PRI.org, Retrieved from https://www.pri.org/stories/2013-01-03/pakistanis-question-governments-use-bans-cell-phones-other-tech.
Richard Chauvel and Ikrar Nusa Bhakti, The Papua Conflict: Jakarta’s Perception and Poli-cies, Washington: East-West Center Washington, 2004.
Ridwan Khairandy, Hukum Administrasi Negara, Jakarta: Rajawali Pers, 2006.
Robert A. Dahl, The Past and Future of Democracy, Siena: Centre for the Study of Political Change, 1999.
Robert Alexy, “Proportionality, Constitutional Law, and Sub-Constitutional Law: A Reply to Aharon Barak”, International Journal of Constitutional Law 16, no. 3, (2018).
Sanford Levinson, "Constitutional Norms in a State of Permanent Emergency", Georgia Law Review 40, no. 3 (2005).
Sefriani, “Kewenangan Negara Melakukan Pengurangan Dan Pembatasan Terhadap Hak Sipil Politik, Jurnal Konstitusi 1, No. 1, (2012).
Simon Philpott, “This Stillness, This Lack of Incident: Making Conflict Visible in West Pa-pua”, Critical Asian Studies 50, no. 2, (2018).
Swagata Yadavar and Athar Parvaiz, 2019, “In Jammu & Kashmir, the Shutdown Has Brought Modi’s Pet Health Scheme to a Grinding Halt”, Scroll.in, Retrieved from https://scroll.in/article/936465/in-jammu-kashmir-the-shutdown-has-brought-modis-pet-health-scheme-to-a-grinding-halt.
Terje Rasmussen, “Internet and the Political Public Sphere”, Sociology Compass 8, no.12, (2014).
Thomas P. Power, “Jokowi’s Authoritarian Turn and Indonesia’s Democratic Decline”, Bulle-tin of Indonesian Economic Studies 54, no. 3, (2018),
Tina Freyburg and Lisa Garbe, “Blocking the Bottleneck: Internet Shutdowns and Ownership at Election Times in Sub-Saharan Africa”, International Journal of Communication 12, (2018).
Vasileios Karagiannopoulos, “The Role of the Internet in Political Struggle: Some Conclusion from Iran and Egypt,” New Political Science 34, No. 2, (2012).
Yohannes Eneyew Ayalew, 2019, “The Internet shutdown muzzle(s) freedom of expression in Ethiopia: competing narratives,” Information & Communications Technology Law (2019), DOI: 10.1080/13600834.2019.1619906.
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.28946/slrev.Vol7.Iss1.1018.pp19-46
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.
Sriwijaya Law Review (SLRev) ISSN: 2541-5298 | e-ISSN: 2541-6464 is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
